Fic­tion

Broth­ers

Chayym Zeld­is
  • Review
By – April 2, 2012

This lyri­cal alle­go­ry is a tale of evil. It is an account of Christ’s old­er broth­er whose lust for pow­er dri­ves him to become a major influ­ence among the Romans who rule Judea. Although the sto­ry takes place in the time of Pon­tius Pilate and Herod, the par­al­lels to evil today are stun­ning. Betray­al abounds, but there is no sign of redemption. 

The anti-hero’s con­tempt for all mankind dri­ves him to acts of cru­el­ty for which he suf­fers no remorse. He plans his betray­als with cold pre­ci­sion and car­ries them out in the same way until he him­self is betrayed. He under­stands treach­ery well enough not to be daunt­ed by it. He mere­ly changes his tac­tics to reach a final goal, the betray­al of his broth­er Jesus to the Roman authorities. 

In spite of the unre­lent­ing evil in this mon­u­men­tal work, it is a book the read­er can­not put down to the very end. We yearn to know the why of malev­o­lence. The nov­el graph­i­cal­ly describes, but does not explain. Some­how, that seems right. Who can explain Judas? Who can explain Hitler? Who can explain Osama Bin Laden? Who can explain anti-Semi­tism? Evil weaves in and out of this work seam­less­ly, invid­i­ous­ly, as if it has a per­fect right to promi­nence in the world. 

In a new pref­ace to the 30th anniver­sary edi­tion, the author adds a unique ratio­nale for writ­ing this riv­et­ing work. It is “…to reclaim with burn­ing pride the kin­ship of my broth­er, Jesus Christ of Beth­le­hem and Nazareth, unequiv­o­cal­ly, irre­versibly, and irrefutably, for the Jew­ish peo­ple. For when all is said and done, it is from the ancient soil of this Land of Israel that Jesus sprang into the sky.”

Pearl Wolf is the author of Song of Miri­am, a his­tor­i­cal nov­el about Jews in Rus­sia in the time of Cather­ine the Great. Her most recent nov­el is Dying to Teach, a con­tem­po­rary sus­pense. She is cur­rent­ly at work on the first of a series of his­tor­i­cal novels.

Discussion Questions