By
– January 9, 2012
The legends in Donkeys on the Roof are a mix of ancient and timeless with some modern features thrown in. They are the ultimate example of the very Jewish style of answering a question with a story. The twelve tales address family life and relationships. They leave the reader with morals and wisdom such as “Don’t judge a person on how he appears.” The first story, There’s No Place Like Home begins, “The teacher Rabbi Yose was known for his patience.” But one student just did not learn. Rabbi Yose discovers that the student was homesick for the town of Great Snoring, a community laughable to all but the boy who missed his hometown, a place that was “so hot that even the camels won’t stray from the air-conditioning.” (Huh? Isn’t this long, long ago?) The book is a wonderful introduction for children to that very particular Jewish approach to finding our way in the world by looking at the examples of sages and rabbis. The Aggada, or Jewish folklore, in this book are proverbs, parables, and explanations of holy texts told in sermons. Over the years, these stories were written down and can be found in the Mishna, Talmud, and Midrash. Chapters of the book are great bedtime stories that can transport readers to a time long ago. However, the drawings are weak and cutesy and the modern-day remarks that attempt to link old with new often break the writer’s rhythm and are a bit too cloying and out of character. Recommended for all ages.
Dina Weinstein is a Richmond, Virginia-based writer.