By
– January 16, 2012
Stephanie’s third-grade class is preparing for the arrival of Ziv, a new student from Israel. Together the class learns about the history, geography, culture, and accomplishments of Israel. There are maps, a recipe for hummus as well as an introduction to a few basic Hebrew words. The book opens with, “New kid alert!” an invitation to join in the excitement of the class. The class is presented in the first and last chapters, the interim chapters read like a text book of what the students in Mr. Louth’s class may research before being introduced to Ziv, the new student. It is difficult to write an objective piece about Israel in any context, and this book approaches objectivity. There are some beautiful photographs of the Baha’i Temple, Caesaria and Bet She’an. A heavy emphasis is placed on juxtaposing the old and the new and portraying Israel as a modern country built on the old. On the other hand, the map presented has the Golan Heights being a part of Syria, a boundary that is factually inaccurate. The West Bank and the Gaza Strip are delineated as separate entities. In addition, many of the Jews presented are ultra-orthodox, which does not give an accurate portrayal of the current population. Arabs are not seen in any of the pictures, and the Dome of the Rock is referred to, incorrectly, as a mosque. The first people mentioned in the timeline of conquerors are the Babylonians, it is therefore difficult for students to understand where King Solomon fits in when he is mentioned on the next pages. The author states that European Jews decided that they wanted to go to the Land of Israel due to Hitler, disregarding the fact that political Zionism began over forty years before Hitler rose to power. There are many interesting tidbits to draw the students in and to make Israel a relevant modern country including the fact that Jesus was a Jew from that region, technological advancements, and parallels in childhood hobbies. The book is appropriate in a school setting for students in grades 2 – 5 under the direction of a knowledgeable teacher with educational materials that counter some of the inaccuracies.
Drora Arussy, Ed.D., is an educational consultant who specializes in integrating Jewish and secular studies, the arts into education, and creative teaching for excellence in Jewish education. She is the mother to four school-age children and has taught from pre-school through adult. Drora is an adjunct professor of Hebrew language at Drew University.