At Hanukkah, the Knoodles family attempts to follow their rabbi’s advice, “It’s hard to give the perfect gift, one that will be treasured forever.” Bubby Sadie gives little Yekl a pickle barrel, Mama Pearl gives Papa Jack a straw hat with yellow daisies, Papa gives Mama a red guitar, Shayna gives Bubby a curling iron (even though she hardly has any hair to curl!), and Yekl gives his sister Shayna jumping tree frogs. Everyone is miserable until the rabbi clarifies his advice: the perfect gift should be a treasure to the person who receives it, not to the person who gives it. The family members all exchange their gifts with each other and everyone is happy, making it “the best Hanukkah ever.”
The illustrations are wonderfully expressive, bright, colorful, and full of humor and life. However, they depict a contemporary family with Mama sporting cowboy boots, pony-tailed Papa riding a motorcycle, and Shayna’s mouth full of braces. This all seems inconsistent with the text. Young children today, like Shayna and Yekl in the story, would not have a Bubby named Sadie from the Old Country who longs for a pickle barrel— she would be their great-grandmother (or their great-great-grandmother), not their grandmother. And their parents, Pearl and Jack, wouldn’t speak with Yiddish inspired expressions and intonation. It seems more likely that the Knoodle family would be contemporaries of the family depicted in Barbara Diamond Goldin’s charming book, A Mountain of Blintzes, which takes place on a farm in the Catskills in the 1920’s. Today’s readers won’t relate to these characters, who are a few generations behind, and will unlikely be charmed by their silliness. Grade Level: PK – 2.
Rachel Kamin has been a synagogue librarian and Jewish educator for over twenty-five years and has worked at North Suburban Synagogue Beth El in Highland Park, IL since 2008, currently serving as the Director of Lifelong Learning. A past chair of the Sydney Taylor Book Award Committee and past editor of Book Reviews for Children & Teens for the Association of Jewish Libraries News & Reviews, her articles and book reviews appear in numerous publications. She has been a member of the American Library Association’s Sophie Brody Book Award Committee since 2021.