Thirteen-year-old Clare has died and has been reborn as a cat. As a girl, she lived in Bethlehem, Pennsylvania and was irresponsible, thoughtless, unkind and immature. As a cat, she lives in Bethlehem in the area that the author calls the West Bank and that many Israelis call Judea.
Clare-the-cat has no political opinions at all, in fact she still has the sensibilities of Clare-the-girl who cared little for such issues. As a cat, she is interested in finding enough food to survive in the semi-wild and wants to be safe from the more territorial animals in the area. And yet she finds it is almost impossible, cat or not, to remain aloof from the issues if she is residing in that particular spot in the world in that particular moment in history. Due to circumstance, she finds herself taking shelter in a house along with two Israeli soldiers and she finds a young Arab boy hiding in the house, as well. The situation is potentially explosive and becomes more and more so as events unfold and a mob gathers and as emotions relating to political, social, and cultural events begin to percolate.
Has Clare learned anything from her life as a human being that she can apply to her life as a cat to make the situation better for anyone? After having lived a selfish and uncaring life as a person, would she want to help anyone now even if she could? And can one turn a powerless state of being into something more if one is motivated and resourceful?
Interesting and off-beat, simultaneously simple and complex, this book walks a fine line which verges on taking a too-strong political viewpoint but just manages to steer clear of the pitfalls while giving the reader much food for thought. The characters each have enough nuanced moments to provide some counterpoint to typical stereotypes and to show that human beings are complicated and not really that easy to pigeonhole. The moral dilemmas are unfortunately all too real.
Clare is written in a quirky voice with many touches of humor and she shows growth and increasing depth as the story unfolds. This would be an interesting book for discussion in a group setting and would spark some lively debate.
Michal Hoschander Malen is the editor of Jewish Book Council’s young adult and children’s book reviews. A former librarian, she has lectured on topics relating to literacy, run book clubs, and loves to read aloud to her grandchildren.