In The Tree in the Garden, Miriam Oren and Peninnah Schram have rewritten the story of the Garden of Eden in Genesis, casting it in a feminist and politically correct mode. The snake is no longer wily and sly, but a wise and beneficent old gentleman. Knowledge of good and evil is reduced to knowledge of good and bad. God’s warning to Adam that eating the fruit will result in death is softened. It will only result in his having to leave Eden. Most emphatically, Eve commits no wrong, but on the contrary, makes a wise and courageous choice in eating the fruit. We are advised to be grateful to her and follow her example.
Shayna, the graceful granddaughter (grandsnake?) of Eden’s famous serpent, narrates the story. It was Shayna’s grandfather who was Eve’s wise and kind advisor, encouraging her to consider eating the fruit of the Tree of Knowledge. If you can suspend disbelief to accept a Yiddishe maidel of a snake named Shayna telling this story to rapt listeners, this book may please you. On the page, the story seems loaded with messages, and a corrective to the chapter in Genesis. Read aloud by master storyteller Peninnah Schram, one can imagine this would make a stimulating D’var Torah or discussion opener.
The book is a slim and attractively designed paperback, printed on high quality paper in beautiful and legible typeface. It is illustrated with lighthearted watercolor paintings by Alice Whyte. The airy, casual landscapes suggest how Eden might have looked under a liberal God. Trees, foliage and humans seem carefree. Only the snake has a heavy presence.
Midrash is an interesting form. When it becomes revision is up for debate.
This book has the potential to generate discussion and stimulate writing and storytelling. It is recommended as an addition to synagogue libraries, women’s studies collections, and Havurah storytelling shelves.