This piece is one of an ongoing series that we will be sharing in the coming days from Israeli authors and authors in Israel.
It is critical to understand history not just through the books that will be written later, but also through the first-hand testimonies and real-time accounting of events as they occur. At Jewish Book Council, we understand the value of these written testimonials and of sharing these individual experiences. It’s more important now than ever to give space to these voices and narratives.
Sunday, October 8: my fifty-third birthday. Tzipora (age thirteen) says to me, don’t worry, Ima. I think your fifty-fourth birthday will be a good one. There is no news on Aner Shapira or Hersh Goldberg-Polin, the two boys from our community who disappeared at the rave in the south. Hersh’s parents have been friends of mine for decades, since we went to high school in Chicago together. Aner’s sister is the close friend of Priya, my nineteen-year-old. But there is no news, just more and more reports of missing people, accompanied by photos of faces and phone numbers. The phone numbers belong mostly to siblings. Young themselves, they are more connected to social media than their parents. They are searching, searching, for anyone who saw their missing loved ones any time since early Saturday morning when it seems that every last cell phone in the world lost contact.
The WhatsApp pings don’t stop. Mostly from my synagogue community, where the group chat has turned into one large posting ground for calls for help: for soldiers, for communities uprooted from the south. (Unrecorded — the silent, constant support for the two families with missing children.) I collect unopened toiletries from the closet, grab Hebrew books and games for kids without my usual hesitation (which books can I part with?), toss them into two large shopping bags. I meet my friend Diane on the corner, and we carry the bags across the street to the courtyard of an apartment building. Three older teenagers are organizing what appear to be already hundreds of drop-offs.
At home, Tzipora and a friend have gone over to B’nei Akiva, the youth movement on our street corner, where they are packing boxes for soldiers, filling them with food that continues to be dropped off, and cards the kids are making. Tzipora hasn’t gone to B’nai Akiva in at least two years, and in general, she isn’t a joiner. On a normal day, this would be enough to stop me in my tracks. Later, she makes me smile when she tells me that a young boy asked her how to spell something for the card he is making, but she is dyslexic, so together they decide spelling doesn’t matter. Priya, nineteen, rests curled up on her bed, in advance of return to her army base in the south. All the worries of the weekend – what assignment will she get at the end of her training course? How will she do on the presentation she needs to give in front of 130 other soldiers? – all those worries have receded. Shai, sixteen, is at Tzofim (Scouts), his second home, loading heavy cartons, going back and forth with his friend who is old enough to drive. They fill the car, then drive to a nearby neighborhood where emergency workers unload it.
We decide to have an early dinner with the family of Nomi, my oldest friend in Jerusalem, minus her two kids in the army, and my visiting friend, Diane. I have known them both since I was ten. Diane goes shopping for some things, later I see she has stocked my fridge for me, surreptitiously. She makes tajine and rice. We open a bottle of wine. There is a homemade card for my birthday. Priya’s friend made her rugelach to take back to the base but she turns them into my cake. Along with some small chocolate souffles that Nomi’s youngest makes from a mix with Diane. When we walk home in the dark, the streets are empty.
Before Priya goes to sleep, she packs up all her things. She showers, climbs into bed, with clean sheets, clean hair, clean body. I sit beside her in the dark. I say, “I’m just going to sit here for a few minutes.” After some time, a little talk about what awaits her at the base, the questions as to what soldiers training for the Education Corps can possibly do in this national disaster, she says quietly: “I’m scared that Hersh and Aner are dead.” And suddenly she is a child again, speaking in the simplest syntax: “I’m scared that.”
I say, “I know. Me too.”
I stroke her arm, I tell her it’s important to take care of herself, that we are here and we love her, that she can call any time. I kiss her goodnight.
Monday: In the morning, I take Priya to the train. She doesn’t want to eat. The streets are absolutely empty. I can drive right up to the corner of the central train station. At any other time, what I’m doing would be attended with crazy honking from all directions. I stop the car and wait for her to get out, without any cars approaching, only another soldier on the street corner who watches while I take a photo of her back, as she crosses the huge street. Large backpack. Army boots. The girl she grew up with in Ann Arbor has written to her ten years later, to send love. From college.
I drop Shai at a nearby community center with his friend. Kids there have parents who are doctors, working at hospitals, called up or covering for doctors who are called up. I don’t expect to see him until evening. He’s at an age where he and his friends will direct themselves. Later, I see a photo of him his father has posted on Facebook, holding up a puppet or stuffed animal in front of lots of kids sitting on the floor. He looks so tall to me. He was the child on the rug only recently.
The pings don’t stop. But no news on Aner or Hersh. No news. I text Hersh’s parents a short line each. I don’t tell them that I simply cannot stop thinking about them, that I couldn’t sleep most of the night, thinking about Hersh. I say only, “With you. Praying.”
WhatsApp pings. Now I collect sheets, towels, cooking things, garbage bags, an electric burner to give to an acquaintance; he has just let us know about 200 Thai agricultural workers who ran from the south after seeing their friends abducted and slaughtered. Will they be able to fly home? Will they stay here? To work what land now? Do they understand what is happening? He loads the things into the already very full trunk of his car, with his son. Last year, this family happened to inherit my son’s bunk bed as their young child was ready for a larger bed. Now we are trying to rescue people together with old sheets (Shai’s childhood sheets from Target, with footballs and soccer balls) and extra large garbage bags.
Shai comes home late at night. He has eaten well from food brought to feed the volunteers, and still, he is so hungry because he is sixteen. Schnitzel late at night.
Facebook is full of missing people. I am starting to understand how many people are dead in the south. I am scrolling non stop in between everything else.
Tuesday. I don’t know what to do with myself. My friend Yael is making sandwiches for soldiers at the café her daughter works at. She is wrapping them in plastic, an assembly line. Wearing the café apron. She takes a selfie and sends it to me. Vestiges of the normal. She says they aren’t taking any more volunteers right now.
I don’t want to leave Tzipora at home to volunteer anywhere more than a few minutes away so I gather up more supplies for understocked soldiers: socks, black and olive undershirts, Vaseline, athletes foot spray. I argue with Tzipora about taking it to the corner. She doesn’t want to leave the house. She goes with Diane, who is staying with us now that we have Priya’s empty bed. We need company.
I go to the store. There is no food on the shelves. No eggs. No milk. No bread. I make cinnamon muffins with what’s in the house.
No word from the missing friends.
I want the government to resign — from Bibi downward. How can three days have passed and still, we have no emergency government? How can no one from the government have gone down to the south to see what is there? How can no one have addressed the families of our hundred-plus hostages? A friend says what we are all thinking: “we’ve been abandoned ‘al maleh.’” That’s the celebratory phrase of the right from when they were elected: a right wing government “al maleh,” they promised, full-steam ahead. Full-full. This is what it looks like: no state, al maleh. Each man for himself. Literally. Except that luckily this is a state full of people who don’t believe that shit. Even many of those who voted for it. And now all those people are what we’ve got without a State.
I get eaten up thinking of the months of demonstrations – all the warnings Bibi got that the judicial overhaul was putting the country at unconscionable security risk – and all the ministers who said that Israel didn’t need the US for anything. Eaten up. I know I am not alone.
I sit down to send short messages to a number of my Palestinian students. Just a line or two to say I am thinking of them and that I hope they are safe in these terrible days. I write because I care about them and because there will be a day after. Also, I have no idea what they are experiencing right now. One student writes back to say she is falling into a ״harsh depression,״ and she thanks me for my note. Another tells me it is a curse to know both Hebrew and Arabic because it is double the extremity and the violence on her social media. A few don’t reply. Another says her experience at the university is the thing that gives her the most hope. I can picture her perfectly even though she graduated a few years ago.
In the evening, I walk ten minutes to pay a shiva call to a British family whose child was a lone soldier. His parents, I hear as I approach, are moving to Israel. I don’t know when they decided to do that. Many young people congregate under the tent that has been put up for the outdoor shiva. The ones standing around me shuffle nervously because they did not know this person, Netanel Yang, and they do not know his family. A stack of bright photos is being handed around. I move toward the front of the group where the family is sitting. Many young people are just standing, unsure what to do now. I move toward a young woman whom I gather is the sister of the soldier. She is seated on a low mourners’ stool. Standing in front of her, I tell her I didn’t know her brother but that I am so sorry for her loss. I take her hand and tell her that she is not alone. She thanks me, she says it means a great deal. Her mother is laughing in conversation with someone she seems to know and she does not look to me like a mother in grief. Which is an absurdity. What does a mother in grief look like? My short exchange is over and I don’t feel a need to try to speak more with this woman, to ask about her brother as I might in a shiva where I know the family. I say, “May you be comforted from the heavens,” and step backward. I did what I came to do. Others, closer, or differently oriented, will talk and sit longer. On my way out in the dark, I recognize a woman on her way in. We have known each other for decades but not well. We hug as if we are the dearest of friends. Twice. Later I remember that the year her first child was born, maybe twenty-five years ago, I watched her hand him to her husband at the end of Yom Kippur prayers as we all danced and sang with that post-fast, lightheaded emptiness, and I watched him take the baby from her, as if he were the single most precious thing in the world. I realize the once-baby, whom I saw last when he was a tall, shy looking nineteen year old, is likely serving somewhere now.
I text the synagogue group to let people know that more people can arrive at the shiva, that it isn’t massively full. And a friend texts me privately to ask should she go, and I say, they need adults. Teenagers can’t navigate the strangeness and the otherworldly difficulty. They want to help but they don’t know how to do this thing. Not like we do either, I add.
Wednesday. Chocolate chip cookies. Shai seems to be looking for food even more than usual. Comfort food. The oven is warm, the kitchen is hot. My hands do what they need to do without thinking. I text while I bake, because keeping in touch matters.
I want to help but I can’t keep searching for things to do. I see a post on my feminist activist WhatsApp group, asking for help organizing volunteer efforts for families with a parent called up. I get on the Zoom training a little later and within five minutes, I have given my name as a local coordinator in Jerusalem. It actually doesn’t feel like a choice. My job will be to match people, mostly women, who have asked for help, with volunteers. In other words, to find volunteers to babysit, to prepare food, to take a dog out for walks, whatever the needs are. The idea is that most women are sure that someone else has it worse than them, that they don’t need the help badly enough. Our job is to use our emotional intelligence on these phone calls to convince these women it is okay for them to take resources, to get help. Even if they are not absolutely at the very very end of their rope. There are so many people who want to help. We can do this without denying help to the most dire cases. One of the three organizers of this initiative is Yael Yehieli, who founded the group 50/50 to bring women into every room where decisions are made, where opinions are pronounced, where culture is performed, where things happen. Like so many other political resistance groups, this one too is using its databases and all its resources now to help the country. So much for “leftist traitors.” In the absence of a functional state, so many volunteer groups are really just the resistance groups of the last nine months mobilizing now to collect socks, to babysit, to provide toothpaste and ceramic plates for soldiers’ vests, because there is fundamentally no ministry of anything that is functional right now.
In the afternoon, I go for a walk with my good friend across the street. Her son is waiting for a tank on the Gaza border. His own tank was blown up on Saturday, the same day he was transported south mid-morning. In normal times, my friend’s son likes to sing Hasidic melodies with his friends on Shabbat late into the night, so loud we can hear them across the street, and his younger sister escapes to us, to hang out with Tzipora, refuge from the many boys around their kitchen table. So his mom and I walk their dog, drop the compost at the community garden, tell each other what we know. She tells me she has heard that Priya’s friend’s brother, Aner Shapira, was badly wounded. So now I am wondering what this means about our friend, Hersh. I keep sending one-line texts to his parents. One a day. They send back heart emojis. And a message to keep praying. I recall that his mother, Rachel, prayed for our mutual friend, Sheila, when Sheila had breast cancer, invoking her Hebrew name every day. We would talk about it each Shabbat when small groups met to pray during the pandemic. I remember when she took Sheila off the list of people she prayed for because Sheila was out of danger. These are the ways you learn someone’s Jewish name: when someone is in danger, when someone needs your prayers.
My family in America doesn’t know what to do with themselves either. They are texting me like I am texting Rachel. And the only ones not texting are the hostages whose phones were stolen by Hamas. Which is fearsome beyond anything, too. I hear that credit card charges are now appearing, but that is the very, very least of the use to which the phones are being put. And I keep asking Tzipora, are you seeing things you don’t want to see on TikTok, and she says no. And I say, it’s hard to unsee things once you’ve seen them, so please, be careful.
In the middle of this day, I start to write, typing fast, because it occurs to me that I will not be able to remember these days at all unless I record.
Wednesday night, I am making connections between people who have filled out the form for help and those who want to volunteer. I have to make all these phone calls in Hebrew. In general, I hate talking on the phone. With strangers in Hebrew, even more. But I make the calls. A woman with two young children needs her sukkah taken down. When I turn to the second call, it turns out I know the woman — we had oldest kids in the same school. I move into English, as does she. She is a doctor, her husband was called up. Her two youngest children are home with her elderly parents who need help taking care of them. My third call is to the husband who filled out the forms for his wife: she has no car and six children. Can I help find them a discounted rental while he is called up?
I text Shai, “Need a sukkah taken down in Rehavia.” An hour later, he asks me the address. Fifteen minutes later, the woman texts me back that two fantastic boys just took down her sukkah. “Unbelievable,” she says. And I cancel the volunteer from the synagogue who said he could it do it first thing in the morning.
Then I post the request for babysitting help for the grandparents to my synagogue group. Five minutes later, a friend writes back with her teenage daughter’s phone number: I put her in touch with the mother.
And someone I don’t know in the synagogue group says she will find someone to do the car rental cheaply. On some level, this is the easiest job I have ever done.
Diane, who has been cooking and hanging out with Tzipora, will leave tomorrow and that does not feel good. My friend Yael says she and her daughter are staying overnight with friends down the street. Nuclear family does not feel like enough.
Thursday. In the morning, I make more phone calls. It is a relief to wake up and know what I need to do. I feel well enough to joke with Yael: during the pandemic, we would ask each other the end-of-semester teaching evaluation question, “How well has this pandemic met your hopes and expectations?” I text her, “If this war were meeting my expectations better, the gym would be open and there would be eggs at the supermarket.” She jokes back. There is an exchange of stickers.
But by noon, the day has broken apart. Priya texts one line, “The kid from my machlaka [army training group of thirty-five] is dead.” He had been missing. Pri had sat at the kitchen table on Sunday on a Zoom with her commander and I had heard one shaky voice during the question period ask, “But what about X? Has anyone heard from him? No one can reach him?” I had heard the commander say back, strong, confident, “Yes, we know. We are on it. We are in touch with the family. We will update you as we know.”
Now he’s dead.
I ask Priya what his name was: Idan Baruch.
I write back to Priya, can you talk. No, she can’t. I write back, “Priya, nothing about this is normal. We are in a nightmare in which I know you have to just go on, but something like this is large. Remember that.”
Later, she calls me. Her voice is terribly shaky. He was in Kibbutz Be’eri. He was asthmatic. The terrorists set the house on fire. And he was asthmatic, so he tried to get outside to breathe and they killed him. They killed his grandmother. His little brother is missing. His parents and one brother survived.
“Oh Priya.”
“Ima, he couldn’t breathe.”
“I know. I know. I’m so sorry. It is an awful, awful story.”
And then she has to go. She is sure that nothing she is doing matters. That her guarding of the base is utterly superfluous, made up to give them a job.
When we get off the phone, I text Yael because I can’t be alone with, “The kid in my machlaka is dead.” She says, “Now you listen. It’s not normal. Priya’s mother needs to remember that too.” I go for a walk. Every friend I can think of to walk with in my neighborhood has a kid at the front.
I write Priya back later in the day with a new thought. When she was young and couldn’t sleep, I would sit next to her on the side of her bed, and say to her, “Sleep will come.” My friend Devorah had passed that gem on to me, and I gave it straight to Priya. “Sleep will come.” And it always did. Eventually. When she was a senior in high school, her teacher asked them to write about something handed down in the family. She wrote about “sleep will come.”
I saw a post yesterday in which a soldier of two months returned safe, thank god, to her mother after holding out in a shelter, against terrorists, with four other soldiers, for fifteen hours. When her mother asked her how she survived, she said, “Do you remember when I was little and had nightmares, you used to tell me to repeat, ‘I have strength and happiness inside’? So that’s what I did, I repeated it silently so the terrorists wouldn’t hear me, and I imagined light pushing toward the door, pushing the terrorists away.” Thinking of that extraordinary post, in which a mother girded her daughter, years before her daughter was in danger, with the strength to survive, I write to Priya, “Maybe start a breathing practice, in which you say, ‘Breathe in, me, breathe out, we. Breathe in, alone, breathe out, together.’ And do it ten times slowly before you try to go to sleep.”
Later that endless day, I join a WhatsApp group in which volunteers want to make sure that children evacuated from the south to hotels and hostels in Jerusalem still get birthday celebrations. As an aside, someone has written, “Hey, there is a woman here celebrating her fortieth birthday. Is there anyone who can help bring some joy?” When I see that the hotel is ten minutes from my house, I say, “Happy to.” The woman calls me to make sure I am legit, because maybe I am Hamas with an Israeli’s phone. We all worry this now, with people we don’t know. After a few sentences, she gives me the name and I pick up containers of ice cream. I get home. When Shai asks me what I am doing as I curl ribbon around shopping bag handles, I tell him and he looks at me like I’m nuts. I call a young friend, eight years old, and ask her to please make a homemade card. She is something of an artist and tells me it will take longer than the ten minutes I give her, so I give her twenty minutes.
When I arrive at the hotel opposite the massive Jerusalem Theater, there are a hundred empty parking places. The streets are still empty. Shiri meets me in the lobby: she has known the birthday celebrant, Mali, for about six hours. She says, “We will tiptoe to Mali’s door, you at the head of the line, and we will surprise her, singing happy birthday.” I may be the very least likely birthday-parade leader out there. We are a gaggle of three mothers, four or five children, a stroller. Quietly we approach the door and knock and when Mali opens it, Shiri bursts out in boisterous song, “Hayom yom huledet!” We all sing. Mali and I hug. We all hug. She blesses me. She blesses my family. We all bless each other. Shiri is recording this all on video. Mali tells me this is the most beautiful birthday she has ever had. I leave my phone number should they need anything else. They left Sderot in the south in the morning with only a suitcase. Who knows when it will be safe to go back. She blesses my daughter in the army. I go down in the elevator and head back home. When I show Shai the video, he laughs for the first time in days. Really laughs. “Gadol,” he says, meaning, “Amazing, hilarious.” I bet he forwards it to his friends. But a little later, before he goes out, he puts his arm around me, hugging me from his great height, and says, “Ima, I really appreciate all the things you are doing.” I am stuck between happiness that Mali had a good birthday and the near surety that she and I have never voted for the same party in any election. It’s likely that she voted for the government al maleh. What to do with that, I have no idea. What to do with the fact that our government has no strategy, no long-term plan. Forget long-term plan. They don’t even have the hostages at the forefront. So much bluster, so many men who say only, flatten Gaza. We have been there before. And now, even with an emergency government, there is not a single woman with a voice at the table where this war and our future will get decided. One woman has a seat at that table, and her status is: “Observer.”
Finally it is night. Finally. While mixing cake batter, I get on the synagogue Zoom at 9:30. Because I am mixing, I am not sure if I have fully understood what I think I have just heard, a friend saying on the Zoom that Aner Shapira’s parents, Moshe and Shira, were informed today that Aner is dead. That we pray tonight for his soul and for Hersh’s safety.
I can’t breathe. I put down the mixer. I sit down. It is not fully possible for me to believe I have just heard right. Even the things we know can happen, we don’t really believe until we are left no choice.
When I text the friend a few minutes later to make 100% sure I have heard correctly, that I have not misunderstood the Hebrew, or misheard the name, she writes back, “To my great sorrow, you have not misunderstood.”
And now, I am left to figure out how to tell Priya before she sees it on Instagram.
The views and opinions expressed above are those of the author, based on their observations and experiences.
Support the work of Jewish Book Council and become a member today.
Ilana M. Blumberg is associate professor of English Literature and past director of the Shaindy Rudoff Graduate Program in Creative Writing at Bar Ilan University in Tel Aviv, Israel. She is the author of Open Your Hand: Teaching as a Jew, Teaching as an American, Victorian Sacrifice: Ethics and Economics in Mid-Century Novels, and the Sami Rohr Choice Award-winning memoir Houses of Study: a Jewish Woman Among Books.