In 2016, my career took a breathtaking swerve. I left twenty years in money management to become head of a Jewish boarding school in the South. I made this unorthodox career move for two reasons: to perform tikkun olam and to teach.
Teaching proved as rewarding and enjoyable as I had hoped. Tikkun olam, however, was more complicated. The school’s precarious financial condition needed urgent attention and given my background, I thought I could help.
I couldn’t.
The school’s challenges proved bigger than a bad balance sheet. I left before the school closed, but took with me (along with memories and friendships), a conviction and a question.
The conviction: the school setting was a creative muse waiting to be channeled by a receptive author. “Write about this world,” the Jerusalem stone buildings seemed to whisper as I crossed and recrossed the stunning campus, hustling to stay on top of things. Not long after starting the position, I realized that my wife and I were living in an improbable hybrid of Tevye’s Anatevka, I.B. Singer’s Chelm, The Lawrenceville School, and Jewish summer camp. As if those weren’t enough ingredients for an intriguing novel, the school was a melting pot, bringing together Jewish students from around the world, from Hong Kong to Panama City.
The school’s frenetic environment, the closeness and quarreling to which this tight-knit community was prone, and the daily crisis that some parent, teacher, or student would tell me must be solved right now—all of this was energizing, exasperating, and, ultimately, inspirational.
The conviction proved out. I listened to that muse — she has a quirky sense of humor — and the result is my first novel, The Academy of Smoke and Mirrors: A Boarding School On The Brink. It is a comic novel, following head of school Jeff Taylor, who wants to resign before his school fails. But Jeff never seems to be able to get out the door because there’s always a new mess that must be fixed first.
I sometimes pointed out that the two greatest leaders of the Torah, Moses and Joseph, were both brought up away from home, where they learned to be leaders.
Writing humorous fiction is challenging. Sure, there was that muse, but co-writer Jim Parry and I also sought guidance from two great novels that caught the spirit we hoped to evoke. Those novels are Catch-22 by Joseph Heller and The House Of God by Samuel Shem, each famous for portraying with black humor the absurdity of working in a large bureaucracy whose culture has long ago lost touch with reality. (The bureaucracies being the US Army in Catch-22 and a large New York City hospital in TheHouse Of God.) Over the five years it took for Jim Parry and I to write The Academy of Smoke and Mirrors, we would often revisit those texts, treating them the way rabbis do the Talmud, as a source of wisdom and a how-to manual.
It is my dream that in that mysterious place where notable literary characters wait to be summoned to a sequel by their creators (or reimagined in fan fiction), Samuel Shem’s Fat Man and Joseph Heller’s Yossarian are sharing a laugh with newcomers Jeff Taylor and Rabbi Benjamin Baum.
I mentioned that my time as Head of School also left me with a question: can a boarding school that seeks to be the Jewish Lawrenceville succeed? (The Lawrenceville School, one of America’s elite boarding schools, is famous for offering its students an outstanding education and for producing many distinguished graduates.)
I think the answer is yes, and I think such a school could do for the American Jewish community what Lawrenceville and its peers still do for America, namely prepare a steady stream of young people for leadership. Before making the case, I must acknowledge that the track record is not encouraging. There have been two such prominent Jewish boarding high schools, one in the US and one in England, and both eventually closed.
The case for a Jewish Lawrenceville rests on something I saw at the school I headed, something moving and noble. That school inculcated into its students a belief in something greater than themselves, a collective mission for them to serve. Now, since the school was a Jewish institution, there would have been an unending dispute were it required to precisely identify that mission. But, in the end, almost all would agree that graduates left the school prepared and eager to devote themselves, in part or whole, to strengthening the Jewish people. Recognizing this achievement, let us return to the question. Can a Jewish boarding school succeed?
I believe it can.
And as the need for leadership in America, both secular and Jewish, becomes more acute, and as the search for ways to cultivate it intensifies, I believe some bold philanthropist will start a new Jewish boarding school, one with a model that avoids the weaknesses of its predecessors, while continuing to instill that mission.
When I was headmaster, I often heard that a school which has children living away from home is in tension with Jewish values. I sometimes pointed out that the two greatest leaders of the Torah, Moses and Joseph, were both brought up away from home, where they learned to be leaders. Perhaps there is a message in the way they were prepared for their missions, one that should inform Jewish educational policy.
Alex Troy worked at two Jewish schools, teaching history at one and serving as Head of the other. Before becoming an educator, he worked as a lawyer and investor for thirty years. He recently published his first novel, The Academy Of Smoke And Mirrors: A Boarding School On The Brink. Alex is a graduate of Yale, Harvard Law, and St. John’s College.