How did American Judaism develop into four main denominations — Orthodox, Conservative, Reform, and Reconstructionist? How did each of the movements shape each other’s history? Michael R. Cohen addresses these questions in his meticulously researched book, The Birth of Conservative Judaism: Solomon Schechter’s Disciples and the Creation of an American Religious Movement.
Cohen vividly describes how the Conservative movement grew out of the nineteenth century German Jewish objective of reconciling “tradition and modernity” in Judaism. Cohen documents how the early founders of Conservative Judaism were committed to “Klal Yisrael” — keeping all Jews united while at the same time allowing traditional Jewish law to be reconciled with modern life through the scientific and scholarly study of Judaism. This perspective followed immigrants to New York City where its adherents established the Jewish Theological Seminary in 1886. But it wasn’t until 1902, when Solomon Schechter was hired to lead JTS, that the seminary became a thriving place of learning and leadership.
Schechter, who was chosen to lead JTS because he was widely recognized as a prodigious scholar who excelled in both Talmudic and secular studies, was born in Romania sometime between 1847 and 1850 into a Hasidic family. He attended several yeshivas including the one in L’vov Ukraine but moved to Berlin and then Vienna, where he gave up wearing his Hasidic garb, to further his education.
Schechter recruited a world-class faculty at JTS and accepted a diverse group of students whose practices ranged from traditional Orthodoxy to liberal observance. He envisioned that JTS would serve all Jews, while making Judaism compatible with modern American life and without sacrificing a commitment to Jewish law. Under his charismatic mentorship, an activist group of disciples developed who adhered to his guiding principles. These new JTS rabbis formed a “group consciousness” through friendship and shared experience. But by the 1950s, most of the JTS graduates and faculty no longer had personal and intellectual ties to Schechter and his disciples. It was in this period that JTS faculty and rabbinical graduates, along with members of the laity, reshaped the Conservative movement into a third stream of Judaism and initiated steps that ensured it was distinguished from the Orthodox and Reform movements.
One might ask, “Why read a book about the development of Conservative Judaism if you are not an adherent of that perspective?” The answer is because reading this book will provide all readers with insight into American Jewish history and the social forces that have shaped it. And because it’s an interesting and well-written book. Abbreviations, index, notes, photos.
Nonfiction
The Birth of Conservative Judaism: Solomon Schechter’s Disciples and the Creation of an American Religious Movement
- Review
By
– August 1, 2012
Carol Poll, Ph.D., is the retired Chair of the Social Sciences Department and Professor of Sociology at the Fashion Institute of Technology of the State University of New York. Her areas of interest include the sociology of race and ethnic relations, the sociology of marriage, family and gender roles and the sociology of Jews.
Discussion Questions
Jewish literature inspires, enriches, and educates the community.
Help support the Jewish Book Council.