The difficulties referred to in the title of this new biography of Lillian Hellman are manifold: not only Ms. Hellman’s widely admired disdain for established norms and expectations, as well as her notorious irascibility, but also the biographer’s acknowledged struggle to see her subject clearly in light of a wealth of contradictory evidence.
Kessler-Harris’s main concern is locating the integrity of Hellman’s political activism on a spectrum whose extremes may be defined by two notable quotes: Hellman’s own defiant “I cannot and will not cut my conscience to fit this year’s fashions,” and Mary McCarthy’s mordant “Every word she writes is a lie, including ‘and’ and ‘the.’” This, it turns out, is no easy task.
The author does an admirable job of mapping the cross-currents of leftist thought in America during Hellman’s lifetime, even if those controversies ultimately seem sadly petty and irrelevant save for the devastation they wrought on the reputations and livelihoods of so many who participated in them. (Did any of those quarrels among American Marxists, Stalinists, Trotskyites, and outright anti-Communists have the slightest effect on the events and personalities they so hotly debated a hemisphere away?)
But she is less successful in defending Hellman’s literary advertisements for herself such as Pentimento, including the story that formed the basis for the film Julia. While Kessler-Harris dutifully defends the right of memoirists to embellish, change, and even invent facts in service of a higher truth, the reader ultimately cannot escape the feeling that Hellman was, as her critics charged, mainly concerned with constructing a more flattering image of herself than a more scrupulous recital of the facts could provide.
Nonfiction
A Difficult Woman: The Challenging Life and Times of Lillian Hellman
- Review
By
– April 17, 2012
Bill Brennan is an independent scholar and entertainer based in Las Vegas. Brennan has taught literature and the humanities at Princeton and The University of Chicago. He holds degrees from Yale, Princeton, and Northwestern.
Discussion Questions
Jewish literature inspires, enriches, and educates the community.
Help support the Jewish Book Council.