By
– September 19, 2011
Fox wakes one morning feeling that “there was something in the air.” He notices pairs of animals marching by in a hurry and joins the procession without quite knowing why. After a long journey, including a night when “tooth and claw and fur and feather…lay down to sleep together” and a detour to free a pair of caged doves in an abandoned city, fox finds a she-fox waiting for him and they enter Noah’s Ark together. The rhyming text is serviceable, although there are few awkward moments as in the forced rhyming of “thought” and “not” and the sudden shifts from couplets to monorhyme. The internal logic is a little shaky as well: it’s odd that all the other animals, including the female fox, know what is going on while the fox does not. Noah’s appearance at the end of the story is a surprise to the fox, and the significance of the ark is not explained in the text. Reid has supplied a springboard from which the religious content can be supplied by readers who bring their own background knowledge with them. This book is best used as a supplement to more Torah-traditional retellings, rather than as an introduction to the Noah story. Despite the weaknesses of the text, Barbara Reid’s signature plasticine art elevates this book to a “must have” level. The bright colors, the variations in texture, the intricate detail, the changes in perspective, and the touches of silent humor all make this a book to pore over again and again. For ages 4 – 8.
Reading Guide
» Download the Fox Walked Alone Reading Guide from PJ Library.
Heidi Estrin is librarian for the Feldman Children’s Library at Congregation B’nai Israel in Boca Raton, FL. She is a past chair of the Sydney Taylor Book Award Committee for the Association of Jewish Libraries.