Juggling Identities is a serious examination of the phenomenon of Crypto-Jewish identity. The book is based on field work conducted by its author, Seth Kunin, over a period of twelve years in New Mexico. Kunin begins with an overview of his methodology (“participant observation” and “unstructured interviews”) including a caveat regarding its limitations.
He then introduces arguments that have been made for and against the authenticity of Crypto-Judaism in the region. In the latter camp is Judith Neulander, whose critique, according to Kunin, is primarily based on the conclusion that rituals which originated within Christian Pentecostalism have been misidentified as Jewish.
Kunin places himself among those scholars who argue that there is historical and ethnographic evidence that substantiates the assertions of cultural self-identity expressed by those describing themselves as Crypto- Jews. Nevertheless, Kunin himself is less focused on the proof of historical authenticity than with the self-understanding of those identifying as Crypto-Jews.
The resulting book is most readily accessible to those with some background in anthropology, although the excerpts from interviews make for fascinating reading for the non-specialist.
Nonfiction
Juggling Identities: Identity and Authenticity Among the Crypto-Jews
- Review
By
– August 31, 2011
Randall Belinfante has served as the Librarian of the American Sephardi Federation for more than 13 years. He has taken a tiny collection of 200 books and built an assemblage of over 10,000 items. Mr. Belinfante holds degrees in various aspects of Jewish studies, and during his tenure at ASF, he has investigated a variety of topics, presenting papers on such diverse topics as the Mizrahi Jews driven from their homes in Islamic countries and the crypto-Jewish Mashhadis of Iran. He has also written many book reviews on books of Sephardi / Mizrahi interest.
Discussion Questions
Jewish literature inspires, enriches, and educates the community.
Help support the Jewish Book Council.