Non­fic­tion

Read­ing Her­zl in Beirut: The PLO Effort to Know the Enemy

December 20, 2023

In Sep­tem­ber 1982, the Israeli mil­i­tary invad­ed West Beirut and Israel-allied Lebanese mili­ti­a­men mas­sa­cred Pales­tini­ans in the Sabra and Shati­la refugee camps. Mean­while, Israeli forces also raid­ed the Pales­tine Lib­er­a­tion Orga­ni­za­tion Research Cen­ter and trucked its com­plete library to Israel. Pales­tin­ian activists and sup­port­ers protest­ed loud­ly to inter­na­tion­al orga­ni­za­tions and the West­ern press, claim­ing that the assault on the Cen­ter proved that the Israelis sought to destroy not mere­ly Pales­tin­ian mil­i­tants but Pales­tin­ian cul­ture as well. The protests suc­ceed­ed: in Novem­ber 1983, Israel returned the library as part of a pris­on­er exchange. What was in that library?

Much of the expan­sive col­lec­tion the PLO amassed con­sist­ed of books about Judaism, Zion­ism, and Israel. In Read­ing Her­zl in Beirut, Jonathan Marc Gri­betz tells the sto­ry of the PLO Research Cen­ter from its estab­lish­ment in 1965 until its ulti­mate expul­sion from Lebanon in 1983. Gri­betz explores why the PLO invest­ed in research about the Jews, what its researchers learned about Judaism and Zion­ism, and how the knowl­edge they acquired informed the PLO’s rela­tion­ship to Israel.

Discussion Questions

Read­ing Her­zl in Beirut reveals a cru­cial miss­ing part in the his­to­ry of the Israel-Pales­tine con­flict. The book explores the fas­ci­nat­ing activ­i­ties of the PLO research cen­ter in Beirut and the stud­ies pro­duced there. It demon­strates, for the first time, the lev­el of curios­i­ty of the PLO towards Israel and how the PLO tried to under­stand their pri­ma­ry foe. Read­ing Her­zl in Beirut shows the depth of knowl­edge and research of Israeli soci­ety, cul­ture, his­to­ry, inter­nal pol­i­tics, and reli­gion. The book illu­mi­nates the com­po­nents of the research cen­ter analy­sis and their respons­es to cur­rent events.

In this incred­i­bly rich account, Jonathan Gri­betz metic­u­lous­ly reads the research prod­ucts out of Beirut but also places them in the con­text in which they were writ­ten: as a con­tin­u­ous attempt to eval­u­ate the intel­lec­tu­al strength of Israel and Zion­ism, appraise its abil­i­ty to har­ness mil­i­tary pow­er, and assess the neces­si­ty of vio­lence in a strug­gle for nation­al liberation.