How the rabbis of late antiquity used time to define the boundaries of Jewish identity
The rabbinic corpus begins with a question – “when?”―and is brimming with discussions about time and the relationship between people, God, and the hour. Time and Difference in Rabbinic Judaism explores the rhythms of time that animated the rabbinic world of late antiquity, revealing how rabbis conceptualized time as a way of constructing difference between themselves and imperial Rome, Jews and Christians, men and women, and human and divine.
In each chapter, Sarit Kattan Gribetz explores a unique aspect of rabbinic discourse on time. She shows how the ancient rabbinic texts artfully subvert Roman imperialism by offering “rabbinic time” as an alternative to “Roman time.” She examines rabbinic discourse about the Sabbath, demonstrating how the weekly day of rest marked “Jewish time” from “Christian time.” Gribetz looks at gendered daily rituals, showing how rabbis created “men’s time” and “women’s time” by mandating certain rituals for men and others for women. She delves into rabbinic writings that reflect on how God spends time and how God’s use of time relates to human beings, merging “divine time” with “human time.” Finally, she traces the legacies of rabbinic constructions of time in the medieval and modern periods.
Time and Difference in Rabbinic Judaism sheds new light on the central role that time played in the construction of Jewish identity, subjectivity, and theology during this transformative period in the history of Judaism.
Time and Difference in Rabbinic Judaism
Discussion Questions
Sarit Kattan-Gribetz’s Time and Difference in Rabbinic Judaism, is a thoughtfully crafted book that examines how the rabbis conceived of time and defined themselves and their surroundings through time-related distinctions. Each chapter examines a unit of time starting with the year and finishing with the day and its subdivisions. The rabbis’ ideas are contextualized within their Roman, pagan, and Christian surroundings, and examined in terms of gendered constructions (men’s time vs. women’s time) and understandings of the divine (God’s time as opposed to that on earth).
The book explores these ideas while presenting a close reading of specific discussions in the Talmud and other late antique rabbinic and non-rabbinic writings alongside a nuanced explanation of the historical circumstances in which the rabbis had to formulate and adjust their changing conceptions of time. This is an original, well-researched, and beautifully written book that opens new pathways for understanding the world of the rabbis and that of their communities in late antiquity.
Help support the Jewish Book Council.