By
– April 24, 2012
Mitchell Lane Publishers’ website states that its goal is to present quality nonfiction through use of “breezy narratives” which will keep kids reading who don’t normally like to read and also help to strengthen their reading skills. Meant as a textbook for students in grades 4 – 7, We Visit Israel is marred by errors and some unfortunate wording. The book is certainly written in a breezy style, starting with the beginning, where the reader is told “This story is based on the author’s years of living in Israel and on her extensive research, which she believes to be accurate.” This is not a story; it is a nonfiction book that discusses Israel’s history, its geography, the Israeli people, their culture, and their government. Like the others in the Your Land and My Land series, it includes full-color photos, maps, a glossary, an index, and a bibliography of works consulted, as well as an activity (a recipe for making hamantaschen) and a craft (making a hamsa). It also includes many errors. Babylonians destroyed the Temple in Jerusalem centuries before the Greek conquerors, yet the book states in two places that it was destroyed by the Assyrian Greeks. The Book of Esther is said to be in the Talmud, rather than in the Bible. In the section titled “Famous Israelis” Saul writes that Jesus of Nazareth “may be the most famous Jew born in Israel,” strangely lumping him together with Golda Meir, Itzhak Perlman, and Israeli-born actress, Natalie Portman.
It is admirable that the author writes with no bias toward either the Jews or the Arabs. However, the many mistakes need to be corrected and, because of the errors listed, We Visit Israel is not recommended.
Andrea Davidson is the librarian of The Temple-Tifereth Israel in Beachwood, Ohio. She holds an M.L.S. from the University of Michigan and is a former member of the Sydney Taylor Book Awards Committee. She enjoys trying out the books she reviews on the kids at the Temple and on her grandchildren.